Florida Perinatal Quality Collaborative

Located at:

Image

Promoting Primary Vaginal Deliveries

Image

Promoting Primary Vaginal Deliveries (PROVIDE) Initiative

 

Did You Know?

  • The Joint Commission will be publishing hospitals with NTSV cesarean rates above 30%      
  • Medicaid managed care plans want to reduce their provider NTSV cesarean rates by 12% by 2024
  • Large cesarean delivery rate reductions does not lead to worsened birth outcomes for mothers or newborns
  • Moms are asking for less medical intervention during labor
  • ACOG and SMFM define active labor beginning at 6 cm rather than 4 cm

momandbaby

Stakeholders across the state and the U.S. have begun to take note of cesarean delivery rates, including their impact on morbidity, mortality, and health care costs.


Project Goal

The goal of the PROVIDE Initiative is to improve maternal and newborn outcomes by applying evidence-based interventions to promote primary vaginal deliveries at Florida delivery hospitals and ultimately reduce NTSV cesareans.

An analysis of Florida birth certificates showed only one-fifth of the hospitals (21%) meet the Healthy People 2020 national goal for Nulliparous Term Singleton Vertex (NTSV) cesarean section deliveries of 23.9% or less. The primary cesarean delivery rate, which drives the overall cesarean rate, among low-risk first-birth deliveries in Florida ranges from 7.35% to 59.8%. Wide variation suggests clinical practice patterns may contribute and provides an opportunity for improvement.


  • PROVIDE Initiative Resources

  • Educational Video Snippets

    The FPQC is hard at work creating a library of short videos for the PROVIDE Initiative. Check back for additions!

    The ARRIVE Trial

    Julie DeCesare, MD, clinical co-lead of the Florida Perinatal Quality Collaborative's Promoting Primary Vaginal Deliveries (PROVIDE) Initiative, discusses the ARRIVE Trial, and whether or not this should change practice and care in Florida. FPQC Statement on the ARRIVE Trial findings and PROVIDE: https://tinyurl.com/FPQCarrive

    Engaging Physicians

    Dr. Karen Bruder, clinical co-lead of the Florida Perinatal Quality Collaborative's Promoting Primary Vaginal Deliveries (PROVIDE) Initiative, discusses tips for engaging physicians in your quality improvement project.

    Labor Positions with a Peanut Ball

    Research shows that use of a peanut ball in labor results in shortened length of labor, and reduced cesarean section rate in epidural patients. We'll walk you through some positions with the peanut ball in the first and second stage of labor. Jessica Brumley, CNM, PhD leads the FPQC's Labor Support Skills to Promote Vaginal Birth Workshops.

    Rotating a Malpositioned Baby

    Knowing some techniques to rotate a malpositioned baby can help avoid a cesarean. The Miles Circuit is a series of positions that are useful to help get the baby lined up in the Left Occiput Anterior (LOA) Position. Jessica Brumley, CNM, PhD leads the FPQC's Labor Support Skills to Promote Vaginal Birth Workshops.

    Why Maternal Positioning Helps Prevent Cesareans

    Why does changing positions during labor help deliver a baby vaginally? Jessica Brumley, CNM, PhD leads the FPQC's Labor Support Skills to Promote Vaginal Birth Workshops.

    What is an NTSV Cesarean Rate

    Cesarean Rates: What's with all the different types? How are they calculated? Why should we focus on NTSV cesarean rates? Dr. Bill Sappenfield, MD, MPH explains what all the rates mean and why the PROVIDE Initiative focuses on NTSV cesareans.

    Standard Definitions of Labor

    Let's all get on the same page when it comes to definitions of: - When active labor begins - Induction vs. augmentation - First stage arrest, second stage arrest, and failed induction Dr. Wilbur Hitt shares the standard definitions used by ACOG and the Florida Perinatal Quality Collaborative.

     

    These can be used in a variety of ways! Here are some ideas:

    • Use as a way to kick off a PROVIDE team meeting or a department meeting 
    • Show at OB division meetings where nursing, physician, and C-suite leaders are present to raise awareness of PROVIDE
    • Share on social media and promote via your website
    • Use at nurse pre-shift briefs
    • Show to OB Chief and OB Medical Director and ask for the best way to present the information at their hospital
    • Perinatal safety team discussions
    • Incorporate into training, education, or events
  • PROVIDE 2.0 Archived Webinars

    • October 30, 2019: PROVIDE Data Collection Information for Hospitals New to PROVIDE

     

    • November 21, 2019: PROVIDE Data for Hospitals Returning to PROVIDE: Reassessment Data Reports

     

     

    In March 2020 we began holding monthly Coaching Calls, which are not recorded. Please visit our PROVIDE Toolbox for past Event Presentation resources.

  • Participating Hospitals

    Advent Health Waterman

    Advent Health Zephyrhills

    AdventHealth Altamonte

    AdventHealth Celebration

    AdventHealth Daytona Beach

    AdventHealth Orlando

    AdventHealth Wesley Chapel

    AdventHealth Winter Park 

    AdventHealth Tampa

    Ascension Sacred Heart Hospital on the Emerald Coast 

    Ascension St. Vincent's Clay County

    Ascension St. Vincent's Riverside

    Ascension St. Vincent's Southside

    Baptist Medical Center Beaches

    Baptist Medical Center Nassau 

    Baptist Medical Center South

    Bayfront Health Spring Hill 

    Bayfront Health St. Petersburg Baby Place

    Bethesda Hospital Inc. 

    Boca Raton Regional Hospital

    Broward Health Medical Center

    Cape Coral Hospital (Lee Health)

    Lakeland Regional Hospital

    Leesburg Regional Medical Center

    Cleveland Clinic Indian River Hospital

    Cleveland Clinic Tradition Hospital (Tradition Medical Center)

    Fort Walton Beach Medical Center

    Halifax Health Medical Center

    HealthPark Medical Center (Lee Health)

    Hialeah Hospital

    Homestead Hospital

    Baptist Health South Florida

    Jackson North Medical Center

    Jackson South Medical Center

    JFK Medical Center

    Jupiter Medical Center 

    Kendall Regional Medical Center

    Lakeland Regional

    Lawnwood Regional Medical

    Manatee Memorial Hospital

    Mease Countryside Hospital (BayCare)

    Memorial Hospital Miramar 

    Memorial Hospital West

    Memorial Regional Hospital 

    Mercy Hospital (Plantation General Hospital)

    Morton Plant Hospital (BayCare)

    Mount Sinai Medical Center

    Naples Community Hospital

    North Florida Regional Medical Center

    North Shore Medical Center

    Northwest Medical Center

    Orange Park Medical Center

    Palmetto General Hospital

    Palms West Hospital

    Parrish Medical Center

    Plantation General Hospital

    Sacred Heart Hospital Pensacola

    Santa Rosa Medical Center

    Sarasota Memorial Healthcare System

    South Florida Baptist Hospital (BayCare)

    South Lake Hospital

    South Miami Hospital

    St. Joseph's Hospital North (BayCare)

    St. Joseph's Hospital South (BayCare)

    St. Joseph's Women's Hospital (BayCare)

    St. Lucie Medical Center

    St. Mary's Medical Center

    Tallahassee Memorial Healthcare

    Tampa General Hospital

    The Women's Hospital at Jackson Memorial Medical Center

    UF Health Jacksonville

    Wellington Regional Medical Center

    West Kendall Baptist Hospital  

    Winnie Palmer Hospital for Women and Babies

    Winter Haven Women's Hospital (BayCare)

  • Archived Webinars - PROVIDE Round 1 (2017-2019)

    May 9, 2019 - PROVIDE 2.0: The Next Generation

    April 11, 2019 - Change Management and PROVIDE 2.0

    February 14, 2019 - Where We Are, Where We Are Going, and Managing the OP Baby

    December 13, 2018 - The Safety and Benefits of Outpatient Cervical Ripening

    October 11, 2018 - Improving and Sharing Data

    August 9, 2018 - The Early Labor Walking Path:  A Tool to Reduce Admission in Early Labor and Reduce Primary Cesarean Section

    June 14, 2018 - Second Stage of Labor: Push it Real Good

    May 10, 2018 - Intermittent Auscultation for Low Risk Women

    March 8, 2018 - Lessons Learned from Implementing an Induction Policy

    February 8, 2018 - Overcoming Resistance to Change

    January 11, 2018 - Where to Start

    November 9, 2017 - Finding Your Cesarean Reduction Opportunities (PROVIDE Data)

Initiative Impact

For most low-risk nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex (NTSV) pregnancies, cesarean birth increases risk of hemorrhage, infection, uterine rupture, abnormal placentation, cardiac events, psychological stress, longer hospital stays, increased pain, and increased postpartum re-admissions. Cerebral palsy and neonatal seizure rates have remained unchanged since 1980. Cesareans are associated with impaired neonatal respiratory function, neonatal intensive care unit admission, difficulty breastfeeding, and lifelong health (Main et al 2011; Smith et al 2016).

Costs associated with cesareans are significant for insurers, government, taxpayers, and consumers. Studies have shown that each cesarean costs $5,000 to $10,000 more than a vaginal birth. Based on Florida reports, maternal hospital cost savings for each Medicaid and private insurance cesarean delivery would be about $4,000. Primary cesarean deliveries are a major contributor to the large increase in cesarean delivery rates in the United States over the past two decades.

Participation in this initiative helps hospitals work in a collaborative with resources to help you implement evidence-based quality improvement recommendations. It also offers an environment to learn together with others on the best strategies, methods and tools to adapt and implement. Hospitals that participate in multi-organization quality improvement collaboratives achieve more gains faster than those who do so alone. Past participants have found it useful to not have to “reinvent the wheel.”